Big Berkey Water Filter Review 2025 – Updated Insights & Alternatives

Pre‑filtered tap water often contains contaminants ranging from heavy metals and microbial pathogens to pesticide residues and “forever chemicals.” Countertop gravity filters like the Big Berkey promise to remove almost everything without electricity, which is why the system has a cult following.

But the landscape has changed in recent years: some U.S. states now restrict Berkey filters because they aren’t independently certified, and the manufacturer is fighting regulatory challenges. This updated review digs into the specs, claims, controversies and competitors so you can make an informed decision.

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Check Price on Amazon

Quick summary

How The Big Berkey Gravity Fed System Works

The Big Berkey is a gravity‑fed water purification system. You fill the upper stainless‑steel chamber with tap or well water, and gravity pulls the water through the Black Berkey elements, which contain activated carbon and ion‑exchange media.

Purified water collects in the lower chamber and is dispensed through a spigot. Each pair of Black elements is rated for roughly three thousand gallons, and the system can hold about 2.25 gallons of purified water at a time. Adding two more elements doubles the filtration speed and overall capacity.

Check Price on Amazon

The stainless‑steel housing measures about 8.5 inches in diameter and around 19 to 21 inches tall when assembled. It doesn’t require electricity, which makes it useful for off‑grid living, emergency preparedness or situations where power is unreliable. Optional accessories include a stand to raise the spigot, a sight‑glass spigot to see water level and silicone plugs to replace the stock rubber plugs.

Contaminants Removed – Claims vs. Evidence

Berkey advertises that its Black elements remove 99.999 percent of viruses and pathogenic bacteria, protozoa like Giardia and Cryptosporidium, heavy metals, trihalomethanes, perfluorinated compounds and pharmaceutical residues. These claims come from Berkey’s own testing and third‑party labs hired by the company.

Independent reviewers, however, highlight a lack of transparency and certification. Berkey has not obtained NSF/ANSI certification and provides limited public test data. California and Iowa ban the sale of Berkey systems because the company has not submitted its products for independent certification, which those states require.

A 2022 lab test by The New York Times found that while the Berkey system effectively removed lead, it was less effective at reducing chloroform than claimed. Other independent tests report similar concerns such as excellent lead removal but mediocre performance against volatile organic compounds like chloroform. Because Berkey hasn’t pursued certification and doesn’t release comprehensive test results, consumers must decide whether to trust the company’s claims.

Regulatory and Legal Issues

In late 2022, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) classified Berkey’s Black filters as “pesticide devices” under the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide and Rodenticide Act because they contain silver as an antimicrobial agent.

This re‑classification would require Berkey to register its filters as pesticides, add warning labels and meet new manufacturing standards. New Millennium Concepts Ltd., the manufacturer, filed a lawsuit against the EPA in August 2023 to prevent this classification.

As part of the dispute, the EPA issued stop‑sale orders for Black elements, meaning dealers cannot sell replacement filters produced after the order. Existing stock can still be sold, and Berkey has partnered with British Berkefeld to offer ceramic filter replacements.

The legal uncertainty has resulted in intermittent shortages and some dealers closing. If you decide to buy a Berkey system, verify that any replacement filters are genuine and be aware that the situation may change depending on the lawsuit’s outcome.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• No electricity required: The gravity‑fed design works anywhere, making it suitable for off‑grid living and emergency situations.
• High advertised removal rates: Berkey claims to remove nearly all viruses, bacteria and protozoa and significantly reduce heavy metals and chemicals.
• Long filter life: Each pair of Black elements is rated for around three thousand gallons, resulting in a low cost per gallon.
• Portability: The system nests for transport and is relatively lightweight compared to reverse osmosis units. It’s popular with campers and survivalists.

Cons

• No independent certification: Berkey has not obtained NSF/ANSI certification and is banned from sale in California and Iowa for this reason.
• Uncertain performance for some contaminants: Independent tests show poor removal of chloroform compared to company claims. The fluoride filters only work optimally in acidic water.
• Legal and supply issues: EPA classification as a pesticide device has led to stop‑sale orders and shortages of replacement filters.
• Slow filtration and maintenance: With two elements, filtration can be slow; adding four speeds things up but increases cost. The system needs monthly cleaning and occasional re‑priming.
• Potential for rubber taste: Using rubber plugs when only two elements are installed can cause water to taste like rubber. Replacing them with silicone or using four elements mitigates this.
• Customer service complaints: Some users report difficulties obtaining refunds or replacements and limited warranty support.

Check Price on Amazon

Big Berkey vs. The Competition

Berkey isn’t the only countertop purification option. Here’s how it stacks up against two popular alternatives:

Is The Big Berkey Worth It?

The Big Berkey remains popular for its portability, long filter life and claim of near‑universal contaminant removal. For people living off‑grid or preparing for emergencies, the gravity‑fed design and lack of electricity requirement are clear advantages.

However, the system’s future is uncertain due to legal disputes with the EPA and stop‑sale orders for its Black elements. Berkey also lacks NSF/ANSI certification, and independent tests raise questions about its performance for certain contaminants.

If you choose to purchase a Big Berkey, buy from an authorized dealer and consider adding a sight‑glass spigot and silicone plugs to improve usability. Be prepared to clean the unit regularly and monitor for taste issues.

Alternatively, if independent certification and verifiable performance are priorities, consider certified alternatives such as the ZeroWater 40‑cup dispenser or the Aquasana AQ‑4000, which carry NSF/ANSI certifications and have shorter but verifiable filter life.

Ultimately, the best water filtration system for you depends on your budget, source water quality and tolerance for uncertainty. Use this review as a starting point, and always consult local water quality reports or conduct your own testing to determine which contaminants are most relevant in your area.

Check Price on Amazon